The Flawed Theology of Separation
Growing up in a fundamentalist evangelical (or “fundagelical”) environment, I was often shown the iconic image of a cross bridging a chasm. This illustration, frequently included in evangelical tracts, conveyed a dire message: because I had sinned—whether by listening to ABBA or sleeping in on a Sunday—I was stuck on the side of death, separated from life and God by a vast chasm. My only hope to avoid death and hell was to confess, repent, and repeat ad infinitum. In this narrative, the cross of Jesus became the bridge to life, as God’s wrath, satiated by Jesus’ sacrificial death, allowed me to escape hell.
One high school chapel speaker explained it this way: imagine you are the world’s greatest jumper standing on the shores of Newport Beach. Your task? Jump all the way to Catalina Island, 26 miles away. No matter how great a jumper you are, you’ll fall short. Likewise, no matter how good you are, you’ve sinned and are separated from God—just as Catalina Island is separated from the mainland. Only Jesus can carry you across. If you don’t ask for forgiveness and accept Him as your personal Lord and Savior, you’ll be forever separated from God in the weeping, wailing, gnashing teeth-filled abyss of hell.
That’s some pretty terrifying theology to tell a room full of teenagers.
Examining the Theology
Let’s unpack the flaws in this theology, starting with the idea that we can be separated from God. Psalm 139 paints a strikingly different picture:
“Where can I go from your Spirit?
Where can I flee from your presence?
If I go up to the heavens, you are there;
if I make my bed in the depths, you are there.
If I rise on the wings of the dawn,
if I settle on the far side of the sea,
even there your hand will guide me,
your right hand will hold me fast.
If I say, ‘Surely the darkness will hide me
and the light become night around me,’
even the darkness will not be dark to you;
the night will shine like the day,
for darkness is as light to you.”
(Psalm 139:7–12, NIV)
One of God’s defining characteristics is omnipresence—being everywhere at once. If separation from God were possible, God would cease to be omnipresent.
Addressing Isaiah 59:2
But what about Isaiah 59:2, the oft-cited verse claiming that sin separates us from God?
“But your iniquities have separated you from your God; your sins have hidden his face from you so that he will not hear.”
On its surface, this seems like proof. However, in context, the separation described here is metaphorical, not physical or relational. In the previous verse, God is described as having arms and ears; in this verse, He is said to have a face. These anthropomorphic descriptions are poetic, not literal.
Isaiah chapters 58 and 59 rebuke Israel for superficial worship. Though they fast and pray, they oppress others and practice injustice. Isaiah warns that God will not respond to their prayers while they live this way. Sin may hinder God’s blessings, but it does not sever His presence or relationship with us. James echoes this sentiment:
“You crave what you do not have. You kill and covet, but are unable to obtain it. You quarrel and fight. You do not have because you do not ask. And when you do ask, you do not receive because you ask with wrong motives, that you may squander it on your pleasures.”
(James 4:2–3, NIV)
God withholds blessings when we live selfishly, but that’s far removed from the eternal damnation described in evangelical tracts.
The Flawed View of God’s Holiness
Another common claim is that God’s holiness renders Him unable to tolerate sin. Supposedly, sin is so abhorrent to God that He must cast sinners into the lake of fire. This view elevates sin as a force more powerful than God’s love and mercy.
Yet Jesus, God incarnate, disproves this idea. He lived among sinful humanity, touched and embraced sinners, healed them, and forgave them. Jesus didn’t flee from sin—He confronted and overcame it. God is not powerless before sin; rather, He is infinitely more powerful. When God encounters sin, He forgives and cleanses, restoring us to relationship with Him.
Bad theology portrays God as abandoning us like an unwanted child. Good theology assures us that God remains near. We may neglect our relationship with Him out of shame or guilt, but He does not separate Himself from us. Instead, He waits, ready to restore and bless when we turn back to Him.
A better analogy might be a patient parent refusing to reward a child’s tantrum with candy. The parent is present and loving, ready to re-engage when the child calms down.
Paul captures this truth beautifully in Romans 8:
“For I am convinced that neither death nor life, neither angels nor demons, neither the present nor the future, nor any powers, neither height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God that is in Christ Jesus our Lord.”
(Romans 8:38–39, NIV)
Even in our sin, God is with us.
Final Thoughts
The evangelical narrative of separation and hellfire relies on fear, but it fails to align with the broader biblical message of God’s presence, power, and love. Scripture assures us that nothing can separate us from God. Sin may obscure our awareness of His blessings, but it cannot sever His relationship with us.
It’s time to leave behind the terrifying images of a wrathful God separated by a chasm. Instead, let’s embrace the God who is always with us, patiently waiting, ready to restore.
Don’t forget to subscribe and thanks to all my current subscribers!
